The approximate second order coupled-cluster method based on a size-consistent Brillouin-Wigner partitioning

We present a variant of the approximate second order coupled-cluster method (CC2) with a two parameter size- consistent Brillouin-Wigner (BW-s) partitioning instead of a Møller-Plesset (MP) partitioning for the unperturbed Hamiltonian, which we refer to as BWs-CC2. The computational complexity of this model scales identically to CC2 with molecular size. Conventional CC2 and its regularized BWs-CC2 variants, as well as conventional MP2 and two of its regularized BW-s2 variants were assessed on a 535 element database spanning thermochemistry, non-covalent interactions, barrier heights and isomerization energies. The assessment was performed using internally stable spin- polarized Hartree-Fock (HF) orbitals in the finite aug-cc-pVQZ basis without counterpoise corrections. Contrary to conventional wisdom, we find that CC2 substantially outperforms MP2 on molecules, showing the value of its single substitutions. While no single choice of regularization parameters can be optimal for all datasets, we find that BWs- CC2 generally outperforms both CC2, and BW-s2 with a single judicious parameter choice. Additional tests on dipole moments and bond-lengths of diatomics provide further support for the utility of this choice. The main outliers and poorest performing cases are associated with large amounts of spin-contamination in the HF reference, which is indicative of systems with either strong correlation or extensive artificial symmetry breaking. Overall, these findings argue that the perception of the quality of the CC2 ground state should be reevaluated and that it can be further improved upon by the soundly based BWs-CC2 variant with the recommended parameter choice.