Developing Force Fields for Accurate Mg2+ and Triphosphate Interactions in ATP∙Mg2+ and GTP∙Mg2+ Complexes
Authors
Comments
The P-OS-P angle of 142.96° is far too large. This comes from charge-charge repulsion if QM calculations in a vacuum. If you look at numerous high-resolution structural data, the average angle is close to 130°. Furthermore, the restraint angle must be smaller than the expected angle because the charge repulsion in AMBER expands the angle beyond the relaxed geometry. The actual angle is a balance of the sum of forces, and this must be accounted for. Proper QM analysis for highly charged molecules requires both statistical averaging of QM analysis with various charge balancing systems (e.g. counter ions and solvent) or at least approximation with charge screening such as GAUSSIAN SCRF, and iterative validation analysis with AMBER energy minimized results versus target restraint angles.