Organocatalytic hydration of activated alkynes
Comments
Interesting step away from the biocat. work. Cool products! Am I overlooking it, or is there no screening data for BSA (or no catalyst) at pH 9.5 and 50 C? I think that would be a valuable control experiment when I look at table S2 and S3 which display a significant increase in conversion by simply increasing the pH.
Response,
Juan Mangas-Sanchez
: Jan 24, 2024, 09:42
Thanks for your comment. You are correct, we haven't done that experiment. Once we found that BSA control was positive we moved towards the screening of specific amino acids since we wanted to determine which one (or ones) were responsible for the activity observed.
Response,
Sjoerd Slagman
: Feb 21, 2024, 16:09
Thank you for your reply, Juan. I am not entirely convinced that there is a significant advantage of the use of Cys over no catalyst at all. I think a test reaction at the standard conditions (pH 9.5 and 50 C) without catalyst would be valuable in order to really see how effective Cys is as a catalyst.