Flavonoids as dual-target inhibitors against α-glucosidase and α-amylase: a systematic review of in vitro studies
Comments
Congratulations to the authors, this is a mammoth systematic review. I particularly applaud the comment in the limitations section regarding the use of non-human enzymes leading to an inaccurate reflection of human α-glucosidase inhibition, this is a crucial take-home message for investigators in the field. The authors go on to mention that "a consensual protocol is needed for in vitro assays using human-sourced enzymes to improve predictive capacity and reduce potential variations in results" and, in the concluding remarks, the authors mention that "future studies should focus on developing consensual protocols for in vitro enzyme activity evaluation and coming up with unambiguous instructions to improve the replication of results." I am pleased to share that we have done just that. Our detailed method for the accurate in vitro quantification of α-glucosidase and α-amylase activities, using human enzymes specifically, was published in Nature Protocols last year: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41596-022-00736-0. Further, we recently published a systematic review on the inhibitory effect of nuts on α-glucosidase activity and found similar limitations (e.g. inconsistent assay methods and enzyme origins) and so, as part of this review article, we developed a Quality Control Checklist to guide future studies on the in vitro inhibition of carbohydrate digestive enzyme activity, which recommends strategies for conducting assays and reporting data. This can be found here: https://doi.org/10.1039/D3FO00328K.
Response,
Thua-Phong Lam
: Jul 07, 2023, 02:12
Hi Michael, thank you for your valuable comments on our systematic review. We appreciate your recognition of the importance of using human enzymes in assessing α-glucosidase inhibition accurately. It is indeed a crucial consideration for investigators in the field. We are pleased to learn about your publication in Nature Protocols, which significantly contributes to improving the reliability and reproducibility of in vitro assays in this area. We apologize for not including this reference in our manuscript, as it was published after the completion of our literature search. Furthermore, your Quality Control Checklist will be highly valuable in ensuring standardized and consistent approaches in evaluating carbohydrate digestive enzyme activity inhibition. We acknowledge the significance of your findings and will incorporate these references and insights into our manuscript for the next submission. Your work will undoubtedly enhance the recommendations and proposed solutions for future studies on the anti-glucosidase activity of chemical compounds.