Thermally Activated Tunneling in the Two-Water Bridge Catalyzed Tautomerization of Phosphinylidene Compounds

Phosphinylidenes are an important class of organophosphorus compounds that can exhibit tautomerization between tricoordinated P(III) hydroxide (R1R2POH) and a pentacoordinated P(V) oxide (R1R2P(O)H) form. Herein we show, using the canonical variational transition state theory combined with multidimensional small-curvature tunneling approximation, the dominance of proton tunneling in the two-water-bridged tautomerizations of phosphinous acid and model phosphinylidenes comprising phosphosphinates, H-phosphonates, H-phosphinates and secondary phosphine oxides. Based on the studied system, the contribution of thermally activated tunneling is predicted to speed up the semiclassical reaction rate by ca. threefold to as large as two orders of magnitude at 298.15 K in the gas phase. The large KIE and the concavity in the Arrhenius plots are further fingerprints of tunneling. The simulations also predicted that the rapid tunneling rate and short half-life span for the forward reaction, as opposed to the reverse reaction in fluorinated secondary phosphine oxides, would result in P(V) being fleetingly stable and only P(III) being isolable, which agrees with previous experiments where only P(III) was detected by IR and NMR spectroscopy. We also explored the role of solvent and predicted tunneling to be substantial.