Moving Mountains: Reshaping the Activity Volcano of Electrocatalysis with Fluxional Subnano Clusters

The activity volcano derived from Sabatier analysis provides intuitive guide for catalyst design, but it also imposes fundamental limitations on the maximal activity and the pool of high-performance elements. Here we show that the activity volcano for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) can be shifted and reshaped in the subnano regime. The fluxional behavior of subnano clusters, in both isolated and graphite-supported forms, not only breaks the linear scaling relationships but also causes an overall strengthening in adsorbate binding. The metals with optimal adsorbate binding in the bulk form (Pt/Pd) thus suffer over-binding issues, while the metals that under-bind in the bulk form (Ag/Au) gain optimal reaction energetics. In addition, the potential-dependence of isomer energies differ, causing non-linear reaction free energy-potential relations and enabling population-tuning of specific isomers, thereby surpassing the apex of the activity volcano. The shift of the volcano that puts under-binding elements closer to the top is likely general in fluxional cluster catalysis, and can be used for cluster catalyst design.