Dual photoreodox/nickel catalyzed C–N cross-couplings are an attractive alternative to the palladium catalyzed Buchwald-Hartwig reaction, but are limited to aryl halides containing electron-withdrawing groups. We show that the formation of catalytically inactive nickel-black is responsible for this limitation. Deposition of nickel-black further deactivates heterogeneous photocatalysts restricting their recyclability. We demonstrate that catalyst deactivation can be avoided by the combination of nickel catalysis and a carbon nitride semiconductor. The broad absorption range of the organic, heterogeneous photocatalyst enables a wavelength dependent reactivity control to prevent nickel-black formation. A second approach is to run the reactions at high concentrations to increase the formation of nickel-amine complexes that reduce nickel-black formation. This allows reproducible, selective C–N cross-couplings of electron-rich aryl bromides.